Alex Schadenberg looks at Belgium's record:
A study published in the Journal of Pain and Symptom Management – November 2011 titled: Process and Outcomes of Euthanasia Requests Under the Belgian Act on Euthanasia: A Nationwide Survey found that only 5% of requests for euthanasia in
Belgium are refused.
The Belgian study on the process and outcomes of euthanasia requests was part of the “Monitoring Quality of End-of-Life Care Study.”
The researchers sent an anonymous self-administered questionnaire to 3006 Belgian physicians by mail in March 2009. Euthanasia was legalized in
Belgium in 2002.
Since some of the physicians did not practice anymore, some never received the questionnaire and some could not be reached, therefore it was determined that the 914 returned questionnaires represented a 34% (2726) rate of response.
This data in the study found that only 5% of the 363 most recent requests for euthanasia were refused.
The article states:
"We found that only 5% of all requests are actually rejected, which is considerably fewer than in The Netherlands (12%)."
The article then states:
"Unfortunately we have no information on the reasons why the attending physicians from our study refused to grant requests. ...
When a psychiatric disorder is the primary diagnosis, the requests were never granted. Although the Belgian euthanasia law specifically mentions psychological suffering as grounds for requesting euthanasia."
Even though the study that was done in March 2009 found that only 5% of requests for euthansia were refused, it appears that a greater acceptance of euthanasia for people with depression or psychiatric conditions in Belgium has developed since the study was done.
This January it was reported that Belgian identical twins, Marc and Eddy Verbessem, were euthanized in Belgium because they feared becoming blind.
In February it was reported that a woman with Anorexia Nervosa died by euthanasia in Belgium.
Also in February, Tom Mortier wrote an article about the euthanasia death of his depressed mother in Belgium. Mortier stated:
My mother suffered from chronic depression. Two years ago she broke off all contact with me. In April 2012 she was euthanased at the hospital of Vrije Universiteit Brussel (the Free University of Brussels).
The death of my mother has triggered a lot of questions. How is it possible that people can be euthanised in Belgium without close family or friends being contacted? Why does my country give medical doctors the exclusive power to decide over life and death? How do we judge what “unbearable suffering” is? What are the criteria to decide what “unbearable suffering” is? Can we rely on such a judgment for a mentally ill person?
A Netherlands study that was published in 2005 examined euthanasia and depression in relation to cancer patients and found that almost half of all the requests for euthanasia were made by patients who were depressed and 44% of the patients who were depressed requested euthanasia, which represented a 4.1 times greater risk factor for requesting euthanasia.
A similar study in Oregon that was published in 2008 found that 26% of those who had requested assisted suicide were depressed or experiencing feelings of hopelessness.
Exposing Vulnerable People uncovered data proving that in Belgium:
• 32% of the assisted deaths are done without request in the Flanders region;
• 47% of the assisted deaths go unreported in the Flanders region;
• nurses are euthanizing patients even though the law prohibits nurses from doing euthanasia.
There has never been an attempted prosecution for abuses of the Belgian euthanasia law.
The fact that this study done in March 2009 found that only 5% of the requests for euthanasia were denied, indicates that doctors in Belgium are not carefully administering the euthanasia law and the safeguards in the law are not being followed.
The Belgian people should be very concerned that incompetent and depressed people are dying by euthanasia and very few requests for euthanasia are rejected.
Legalizing euthanasia and assisted suicide are not safe.
Links to similar articles.